Quick answer: “RFID” is not one card. ID, Mifare, DESFire, HID and UHF cards are all RFID. The right one depends on what the card is for, how secure it must be, and which reader you already have. The card and the reader must always match.
The Rule Most People Miss: Card and Reader Must Match
An ID reader cannot read a Mifare card, and a normal door reader cannot read a UHF card. If you already have cards, the new reader must support them. If your site mixes card types, WhatsApp us your card types and we’ll advise on a suitable reader.
The 5 Card Types Compared
| Card | In simple words | Read distance | Copy risk | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ID (125kHz) | Basic card that only carries a number | Touch, a few cm | High, easy to copy | Simple door access, attendance, small offices |
| Mifare (13.56MHz) | Has a memory chip, so one card can do several jobs | Touch, a few cm | Medium, Classic cards can be copied | Door, lift and canteen on one card; condos |
| DESFire (13.56MHz) | High-security card with strong encryption | Touch, a few cm | Very low, very hard to copy | Banks, government, data centres, factories |
| HID Prox (125kHz) | The older HID card; only a number, like an ID card | Touch, a few cm | High, easy to copy | Offices already using HID Prox that need more cards |
| HID iCLASS / Seos (13.56MHz) | HID smart cards with encryption | Touch, a few cm | Low (Seos lowest) | Multinational offices and companies whose head office requires HID |
| UHF long range | Read from a distance, so drivers do not stop to tap | Long range; depends on site and how the reader is mounted | Low (encrypted UHF cards) | Car park barriers, condo and factory gates |
ID card (125kHz)
The most basic access card. It only carries a number, so it is quick to set up but easy to copy. Common with readers like the ZKTeco ProID10WE. Need both ID and Mifare on one card? See the ID mix Mifare card.
Mifare card (13.56MHz)
Mifare cards have a memory chip, so one card can open doors, call lifts and pay at the canteen. Classic Mifare cards can be copied, so they suit everyday sites rather than high-security ones. Read more: Different types of Mifare card.
DESFire card (13.56MHz)
DESFire is the high-security version, with strong encryption that makes the card very hard to copy. Pair it with an encrypted DESFire reader. See the ZKTeco DESFire access control solution and encrypted vs non-encrypted DESFire readers.
HID cards: Prox and iCLASS / Seos
HID is a US brand used by many multinational offices. HID Prox (125kHz) is the older type and works like an ID card. HID iCLASS and Seos (13.56MHz) are encrypted smart cards, similar to DESFire. Check the card: “Prox”, “iCLASS” or “Seos” is usually printed on the back or edge. See HID iCLASS SE, HID Seos and the HID Signo 20 reader.
UHF long-range card
UHF cards are read from a distance, so cars drive in without stopping to tap a card. They are used at car park barriers and guardhouse gates. The actual read distance depends on the site and how the reader is mounted, so we advise after seeing your site. See the ZKTeco UHF10F Pro reader and encrypted UHF cards. Barrier arm damaged? See barrier arm replacement.
4 Questions to Choose the Right Card
- What is it for? Door, lift, attendance, car park or canteen?
- Do you already use cards? Take a photo of your card and reader. New readers must match old cards.
- How important is security? Normal office: ID or Mifare. High security: DESFire or HID iCLASS / Seos.
- Walking or driving? Driving: UHF. Walking: the other cards.
Not Sure Which Card You Have?
Send a photo of your current card (front and back) and your reader on WhatsApp 019-348 1168. We will tell you which card it is and what works with it. We supply across Malaysia, with our Penampang branch serving Sabah and Sarawak.